| Round | Overall | Player |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4th |
1B
Jeff Bagwell
|
| 2 | 21st |
OF
Bernie Williams
|
| 3 | 28th |
P
Pedro Martinez
|
| 4 | 45th |
P
Mariano Rivera
|
| 5 | 52nd |
OF
Paul O'Neill
|
| 6 | 69th |
3B
Scott Rolen
|
| 7 | 76th |
2B
Jeff Kent
|
| 8 | 93rd |
P
Shawn Estes
|
| 9 | 100th |
P
Darryl Kile
|
| 10 | 117th |
P
Andy Benes
|
| 11 | 124th |
SS
Jose Valentin
|
| 12 | 141st |
DH
Chili Davis
|
| 13 | 148th |
1B
J.T. Snow
|
| 14 | 165th |
OF
Brian Jordan
|
| 15 | 172nd |
3B
Willie Greene
|
| 16 | 189th |
C
Jorge Fabregas
|
| 17 | 196th |
P
John Burkett
|
| 18 | 213th |
OF
Magglio Ordonez
|
| 19 | 220th |
3B
Todd Walker
|
| 20 | 237th |
P
Victor Santos
|
| 21 | 244th |
P
Tony Saunders
|
| 22 | 261st |
OF
Troy O'Leary
|
| 23 | 268th |
P
Jaime Navarro
|
| 24 | 285th |
P
Scott Sanders
|
| 25 | 292nd |
3B
Sean Berry
|
| 26 | 309th |
OF
Shawn Green
|