| Round | Overall | Player |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 11th |
DH
Juan Gonzalez
|
| 2 | 14th |
1B
Mark McGwire
|
| 3 | 35th |
1B
Andres Galarraga
|
| 4 | 38th |
P
Kevin Brown
|
| 5 | 59th |
C
Sandy Alomar Jr.
|
| 6 | 62nd |
P
Denny Neagle
|
| 7 | 83rd |
OF
Jay Buhner
|
| 8 | 86th |
OF
Paul O'Neill
|
| 9 | 107th |
OF
Ben Grieve
|
| 10 | 110th |
SS
Jeff Blauser
|
| 11 | 131st |
1B
David Segui
|
| 12 | 134th |
P
Scott Erickson
|
| 13 | 155th |
P
Jimmy Key
|
| 14 | 158th |
P
Jamie Moyer
|
| 15 | 179th |
1B
Jeff King
|
| 16 | 182nd |
3B
Jeff Cirillo
|
| 17 | 203rd |
C
Chris Hoiles
|
| 18 | 206th |
OF
Jeffrey Hammonds
|
| 19 | 227th |
2B
Jose Offerman
|
| 20 | 230th |
P
Bob Tewksbury
|
| 21 | 251st |
OF
Jon Nunnally
|
| 22 | 254th |
P
Tom Candiotti
|
| 23 | 275th |
P
Kenny Rogers
|
| 24 | 278th |
P
Mark Gardner
|
| 25 | 299th |
DH
Reggie Jefferson
|
| 26 | 302nd |
3B
Joe Randa
|
| 27 | 323rd |
P
Tim Worrell
|