| Round | Overall | Player |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4th | 1B Mark McGwire StL |
| 2 | 21st | C Ivan Rodriguez Tex |
| 3 | 28th | OF Manny Ramirez Cle |
| 4 | 45th | P Trevor Hoffman SD |
| 5 | 52nd | P Curt Schilling Phi |
| 6 | 69th | OF Gary Sheffield LA |
| 7 | 76th | 2B Todd Walker Min |
| 8 | 93rd | P John Wetteland Tex |
| 9 | 100th | 3B John Valentin Bos |
| 10 | 117th | OF Kenny Lofton Cle |
| 11 | 124th | OF David Justice Cle |
| 12 | 141st | SS Royce Clayton Tex |
| 13 | 148th | P Mike Hampton Hou |
| 14 | 165th | P Matt Morris StL |
| 15 | 172nd | P Tim Wakefield Bos |
| 16 | 189th | P Rolando Arrojo TB |
| 17 | 196th | P Charles Nagy Cle |
| 18 | 213th | C Sandy Alomar Jr. Cle |
| 19 | 220th | P Jaret Wright Cle |
| 20 | 237th | P Bret Saberhagen Bos |
| 21 | 244th | P Carl Pavano Mon |
| 22 | 261st | P Mark Gardner SF |
| 23 | 268th | P Bob Wickman Mil |
| 24 | 285th | 3B Bill Mueller SF |
| 25 | 292nd | P Hideo Nomo NYN |
| 26 | 309th | 1B Fred McGriff TB |