| Round | Overall | Player |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 10th |
C
Mike Piazza
|
| 2 | 15th |
1B
Mark McGwire
|
| 3 | 34th |
1B
Rafael Palmeiro
|
| 4 | 39th |
RP
Ugueth Urbina
|
| 5 | 58th |
SP
Bartolo Colon
|
| 6 | 63rd |
OF
Magglio Ordonez
|
| 7 | 82nd |
RP
John Rocker
|
| 8 | 87th |
SP
Shane Reynolds
|
| 9 | 106th |
OF
Brian Jordan
|
| 10 | 111th |
SP
Chuck Finley
|
| 11 | 130th |
SP
Kevin Appier
|
| 12 | 135th |
OF
Jermaine Dye
|
| 13 | 154th |
1B
Richie Sexson
|
| 14 | 159th |
3B
Joe Randa
|
| 15 | 178th |
RP
Ricky Bottalico
|
| 16 | 183rd |
SP
Ramon Martinez
|
| 17 | 202nd |
SS
Jose Hernandez
|
| 18 | 207th | SP Darren Dreifort |
| 19 | 226th |
OF
Henry Rodriguez
|
| 20 | 231st |
SP
Pedro Astacio
|
| 21 | 250th |
2B
David Bell
|
| 22 | 255th |
SP
Justin Thompson
|
| 23 | 274th |
3B
Phil Nevin
|
| 24 | 279th |
SP
Juan Pena
|
| 25 | 298th |
SP
Robert Person
|
| 26 | 303rd |
SP
Omar Olivares
|
| 27 | 322nd |
C
Todd Pratt
|