| Name | Team | Games | PPG | Total Pts. | Pos. | PPG Rank | Total Rank |
| Jose Berrios |
|
31 | 10.32 | 320 | SP | 112th | 53rd |
| Jac Caglianone |
|
62 | 1.90 | 118 | 1B | 78th | 68th |
| OF | 181st | 166th | |||||
| Ernie Clement |
|
149 | 2.56 | 382 | 1B | 40th | 26th |
| 2B | 32nd | 17th | |||||
| 3B | 30th | 12th | |||||
| SS | 34th | 23rd | |||||
| Edwin Diaz |
|
62 | 7.69 | 477 | RP | 37th | 7th |
| Bailey Falter |
|
26 | 9.08 | 236 | SP | 157th | 112th |
| Wilmer Flores |
|
125 | 2.47 | 309 | 1B | 46th | 38th |
| 2B | 44th | 33rd | |||||
| Sal Frelick |
|
141 | 2.97 | 419 | OF | 52nd | 39th |
| Adolis Garcia |
|
135 | 2.77 | 374 | OF | 72nd | 57th |
| Sonny Gray |
|
32 | 12.38 | 396 | SP | 54th | 20th |
| Jonathan India |
|
136 | 2.46 | 334 | 2B | 45th | 26th |
| 3B | 42nd | 18th | |||||
| OF | 118th | 72nd | |||||
| Aaron Judge |
|
152 | 4.99 | 759 | OF | 2nd | 1st |
| Merrill Kelly |
|
32 | 12.84 | 411 | SP | 45th | 16th |
| Matthew Liberatore |
|
29 | 10.34 | 300 | SP | 110th | 64th |
| Nick Lodolo |
|
29 | 11.59 | 336 | SP | 75th | 44th |
| Seth Lugo |
|
26 | 10.85 | 282 | SP | 95th | 79th |
| Jesus Luzardo |
|
32 | 13.34 | 427 | SP | 35th | 12th |
| Andrew McCutchen |
|
135 | 2.60 | 351 | OF | 94th | 67th |
| Ryan McMahon |
|
151 | 2.53 | 382 | 3B | 37th | 12th |
| Jeff McNeil |
|
122 | 2.56 | 312 | 2B | 34th | 32nd |
| OF | 100th | 82nd | |||||
| Max Muncy |
|
60 | 2.15 | 129 | 2B | 71st | 84th |
| 3B | 66th | 78th | |||||
| SS | 59th | 71st | |||||
| Zach Neto |
|
128 | 3.45 | 441 | SS | 9th | 15th |
| Quinn Priester |
|
29 | 12.69 | 368 | RP | 2nd | 19th |
| SP | 47th | 28th | |||||
| J.T. Realmuto |
|
134 | 2.57 | 345 | C | 28th | 13th |
| Nolan Schanuel |
|
129 | 2.88 | 371 | 1B | 25th | 29th |
| Kodai Senga |
|
22 | 11.36 | 250 | SP | 83rd | 98th |
| Brady Singer |
|
32 | 12.00 | 384 | SP | 60th | 23rd |
| Jorge Soler |
|
81 | 2.44 | 198 | OF | 119th | 131st |
| Trevor Story |
|
155 | 3.31 | 513 | SS | 11th | 6th |
| Seiya Suzuki |
|
149 | 3.53 | 526 | OF | 21st | 17th |
| Gleyber Torres |
|
145 | 3.09 | 448 | 2B | 10th | 7th |
| Daulton Varsho |
|
68 | 3.72 | 253 | OF | 10th | 106th |
| Mark Vientos |
|
121 | 2.58 | 312 | 3B | 29th | 30th |
| Eric Wagaman |
|
138 | 2.36 | 325 | 1B | 56th | 37th |
| OF | 126th | 74th | |||||
| Austin Wells |
|
118 | 2.81 | 332 | C | 18th | 14th |