| Week | Add | Drop |
| Pre-Season |
Round A: SP Kenta Maeda  | |
| Week 1 |
Round 1: SP Cody Anderson  Round 2: SP Drew Pomeranz  | |
| Week 2 |
Round 1: SP Brandon Finnegan  Round 2: SP Shane Greene  |
Round 1: OF Hector Olivera  Round 2: SP Cody Anderson |
| Week 3 |
Round 1: 1B Ben Paulsen  Round 2: 3B David Freese  |
Round 1: SP Shane Greene Round 2: 2B Brett Lawrie  |
| Week 4 |
Round 1: SP Kevin Gausman  Round 2: SP Juan Nicasio |
Round 1: SP Juan Nicasio Round 2: SS Brad Miller  |
| Week 5 |
Round 1: OF Adam Duvall Round 2: 1B Mark Reynolds |
Round 1: SP Brandon Finnegan Round 2: C Devin Mesoraco |
| Week 6 |
Round 1: OF Steven Pearce Round 2: SS Jose Reyes  |
Round 1: 1B Ben Paulsen Round 2: 3B David Freese |
| Week 7 |
Round 1: SP Jameson Taillon Round 2: C Chris Herrmann  |
Round 1: SP Juan Nicasio Round 2: 2B Jurickson Profar  |
| Week 8 |
Round 1: SP Alex Reyes  Round 2: 2B Jurickson Profar |
Round 1: 3B Trevor Plouffe Round 2: 1B Mark Reynolds |
| Week 9 |
Round 1: OF Hyun-soo Kim Round 2: C Cameron Rupp  |
Round 1: C Chris Herrmann Round 2: SS Jose Reyes |
| Week 10 |
Round 1: SP Michael Pineda  Round 2: SS Tim Anderson |
Round 2: SP Jose Berrios Round 2: OF Hyun-soo Kim |
| Week 11 |
Round 1: C Willson Contreras  Round 2: 2B Kolten Wong |
Round 1: C Cameron Rupp Round 2: SP Michael Pineda |
| Week 12 |
Round 1: OF Angel Pagan  Round 2: OF Abraham Almonte |
Round 1: OF David Peralta  Round 2: DH Byung-ho Park |
| Week 13 |
Round 1: 1B Mark Teixeira Round 2: OF Steve Souza |
Round 1: OF Abraham Almonte Round 2: 2B Kolten Wong |
| Week 14 |
Round 1: SP Brandon McCarthy Round 2: OF David Dahl |
Round 1: SP Jake Odorizzi Round 2: OF Steven Pearce |
| Week 16 |
Round 1: OF Steven Pearce Round 2: C Mike Zunino  |
Round 1: SP Brandon McCarthy Round 2: 1B Mark Teixeira |
| Week 17 |
Round 1: RP Adam Conley  Round 2: RP Dellin Betances |
Round 1: RP Hector Rondon Round 2: OF Steve Souza |
| Week 18 |
Round 1: OF Andrew Benintendi Round 2: OF Lewis Brinson  |
Round 1: RP Cody Allen Round 2: C Wellington Castillo |
| Week 19 |
Round 1: SS Dansby Swanson Round 2: OF Tyler Austin |
Round 1: OF Steven Pearce Round 2: RP Adam Conley Round 2: OF Angel Pagan |
| Week 21 |
Round 1: OF Bradley Zimmer Round 2: SP Vincent Velasquez |
Round 2: OF Tyler Austin |
| Week 23 |
Round 2: SP Joe Musgrove  |
Round 2: C Mike Zunino |
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | Votes |