| Week | Add | Drop |
| Pre-Season |
Round 1: 3B David Freese - StL |
Round 1: SS Bobby Crosby - Oak |
| Week 1 |
Round 1: SP Koji Uehara - Bal |
Round 1: SP Braden Looper - Mil |
| Week 2 |
Round 1: SP Ricky Romero - Tor Round 2: SP Braden Looper - Mil |
Round 1: SP Koji Uehara - Bal Round 2: 3B David Freese - StL |
| Week 3 |
Round 2: SP Koji Uehara - Bal | |
| Week 4 |
Round 1: 2B Chris Getz - ChA Round 2: OF Jose Guillen - KC |
Round 1: 2B Alexi Casilla - Min Round 2: OF Juan Rivera - LAA |
| Week 5 |
Round 1: SP Josh Geer - SD |
Round 1: SP Kyle Davies - KC |
| Week 6 |
Round 1: SP Matt Palmer - LAA Round 2: OF Michael Bourn - Hou |
Round 2: SP Josh Geer - SD |
| Week 7 |
Round 1: 2B Adam Kennedy - Oak Round 2: SP Jason Vargas - Sea |
Round 1: 2B Chris Getz - KC Round 2: SP John Maine - NYN |
| Week 8 |
Round 1: SP Todd Wellemeyer - StL Round 2: RP Scott Feldman - Tex |
Round 1: RP Brian Wilson - SF Round 2: SP Brett Myers - Hou |
| Week 9 |
Round 1: SP Jeff Niemann - TB |
Round 1: SP Braden Looper - Mil |
| Week 10 |
Round 1: SP Sean West - Fla Round 2: SP Vicente Padilla - LAD |
Round 1: SP Todd Wellemeyer - StL Round 2: SP Jeff Niemann - TB |
| Week 11 |
Round 1: SP Josh Outman - Oak Round 2: C Ronny Paulino - Fla |
Round 1: SP Jon Garland - SD Round 2: C Nick Hundley - SD |
| Week 12 |
Round 1: SP Fernando Nieve - NYN Round 2: SP Joe Blanton - Phi |
Round 1: OF Jose Guillen - KC Round 2: SP Jason Vargas - Sea Round 2: RP Scott Feldman - Tex |
| Week 13 |
Round 1: SP Jeff Niemann - TB Round 2: SP Ryan Sadowski - SF |
Round 1: SP Josh Outman - Oak Round 2: SP Matt Palmer - LAA |
| Week 14 |
Round 1: 2B Chris Getz - ChA Round 2: OF Garrett Jones - Pit |
Round 2: SP Sean West - Fla |
| Week 16 |
Round 1: RP Scott Feldman - Tex Round 2: SP Jon Garland - Ari |
Round 2: SP Ryan Sadowski - SF |
| Week 17 |
Round 1: SP Anthony Swarzak - Min Round 2: SP Rick Vanden Hurk - Fla |
Round 1: RP Scott Feldman - Tex Round 2: SP Aaron Harang - Cin |
| Week 18 |
Round 1: SP Jonathan Sanchez - SF Round 2: C Alex Avila - Det |
Round 1: SP Anthony Swarzak - Min Round 2: C Ronny Paulino - Fla Round 2: 2B Chris Getz - KC |
| Week 19 |
Round 1: 2B Luis Valbuena - Cle Round 2: SS Cliff Pennington - Oak |
Round 1: SS Edgar Renteria - SF Round 2: SP Vicente Padilla - LAD |
| Week 21 |
Round 1: SP Ross Ohlendorf - Pit Round 2: SS Erick Aybar - LAA |
Round 1: SP Koji Uehara - Bal Round 2: SS Cliff Pennington - Oak |
| Week 23 |
Round 1: OF Angel Pagan - NYN Round 2: SP Wade Davis - TB |
Round 1: SP Rick Vanden Hurk - Fla |
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | Votes |