| Week | Add | Drop |
| Week 1 |
Round 1: 3B Jeff Keppinger - Cin Round 2: 1B Ben Broussard - Tex |
Round 2: OF Jonny Gomes - Cin |
| Week 2 |
Round 1: SP Cliff Lee - Cle Round 2: SS David Eckstein - Tor |
Round 1: 3B Ty Wigginton - Bal Round 2: SP Kevin Slowey - Min |
| Week 3 |
Round 1: SP Greg Smith - Oak Round 2: OF Jack Cust - Oak |
Round 1: SP Aaron Cook - Col Round 2: OF Melky Cabrera - NYA |
| Week 4 |
Round 1: SP Aaron Cook - Col Round 2: SP Tom Glavine - Atl |
Round 1: 1B Ben Broussard - Tex Round 2: SP Kenny Rogers - Det |
| Week 5 |
Round 1: OF Wladimir Balentien - Sea Round 2: 3B Ty Wigginton - Hou |
Round 2: SS Alex Gonzalez - Cin |
| Week 6 |
Round 1: SP Justin Duchscherer - Oak Round 2: SS Ramon Vazquez - Tex |
Round 1: SP Jeremy Guthrie - Bal Round 2: SS David Eckstein - SD |
| Week 7 |
Round 2: SP Jon Rauch - Ari |
Round 2: OF Andre Ethier - LAD |
| Week 8 |
Round 1: RP Jay Bergmann - Was |
Round 1: RP Jason Isringhausen - StL |
| Week 9 |
Round 1: SP Kevin Slowey - Min Round 2: OF Randy Winn - SF |
Round 1: 3B Jeff Keppinger - Cin Round 2: OF Cameron Maybin - Fla |
| Week 10 |
Round 1: OF Mark Teahen - KC Round 2: SP Kyle Davies - KC |
Round 1: OF Wladimir Balentien - Sea Round 2: RP Jay Bergmann - Was |
| Week 11 |
Round 1: SP Kenny Rogers - Det Round 2: OF Luke Scott - Bal |
Round 1: SP Kevin Slowey - Min Round 2: SP Tom Glavine - Atl |
| Week 12 |
Round 1: 3B Russ Branyan - Mil Round 2: OF Brandon Jones - Atl |
Round 1: OF Gary Matthews Jr. - LAA Round 2: OF Randy Winn - SF |
| Week 13 |
Round 1: 3B Chad Tracy - Ari Round 2: SP Chan Ho Park - LAD |
Round 1: 3B Ty Wigginton - Bal Round 2: OF Luke Scott - Bal |
| Week 14 |
Round 1: SP Daniel Cabrera - Bal Round 2: SP Collin Balester - Was |
Round 1: SS Ramon Vazquez - Tex Round 2: SP Chan Ho Park - NYN |
| Week 15 |
Round 1: SS Ben Zobrist - TB Round 2: SP Glen Perkins - Min |
Round 2: OF Brandon Jones - Atl Round 2: DH Gary Sheffield - Det |
| Week 17 |
Round 1: SP Oliver Perez - NYN Round 2: C Gerald Laird - Tex |
Round 1: SP Daniel Cabrera - Bal Round 2: 3B Russ Branyan - StL Round 2: SP Collin Balester - Was |
| Week 18 |
Round 1: RP Jason Isringhausen - StL Round 2: OF Luke Scott - Bal |
Round 1: SP Jon Rauch - Ari |
| Week 19 |
Round 1: SP Joel Hanrahan - Was Round 2: OF Marlon Byrd - Tex |
Round 1: RP Jason Isringhausen - StL Round 2: SS Ben Zobrist - TB |
| Week 21 |
Round 1: SP Paul Byrd - Cle |
Round 1: SP Brad Penny - LAD |
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | Votes |
| Week 4 | ||
| Warhammer | Al Davis Clambake | Decision |
|
SP
Tim Lincecum
SP |
OF
Hunter Pence
Hou |
Approved 16-2. See Breakdown |
| Week 13 | ||
| Warhammer | Jersey Thunder | Decision |
|
OF
Vernon Wells
Tor SP Cliff Lee Cle |
OF
Adam Dunn
Cin SS Troy Tulowitzki Col |
Approved 15-1. See Breakdown |