| Week | Add | Drop |
| Pre-Season |
Round 1: SP Dean Kremer - Bal Round A: SP Shota Imanaga - ChN |
Round A: RP Clay Holmes - NYA |
| Week 1 |
Round 1: RP Abner Uribe - Mil Round 2: SS Oswaldo Cabrera - NYA | |
| Week 2 |
Round 1: RP José Alvarado - Phi Round 2: OF Heston Kjerstad - Bal |
Round 1: 1B Carlos Santana - Min Round 2: SP Ricky Tiedemann - Tor |
| Week 3 |
Round 1: 3B Josh Smith - Tex Round 2: SP Martin Perez - Pit |
Round 1: 3B Yoan Moncada - ChA |
| Week 4 |
Round 1: SP José Butto - NYN Round 2: SP Yusei Kikuchi - Tor |
Round 1: RP José Alvarado - Phi Round 2: SP Dean Kremer - Bal |
| Week 5 |
Round 1: SP Mitchell Parker - Was Round 2: SP Keaton Winn - SF |
Round 1: RP Abner Uribe - Mil Round 2: SP José Butto - NYN |
| Week 6 |
Round 1: 3B Nick Senzel - Was Round 2: SP John Means - Bal |
Round 1: C Henry Davis - Pit Round 2: SP Martin Perez - Pit |
| Week 7 |
Round 1: C Gary Sanchez - Mil |
Round 1: SP Keaton Winn - SF |
| 1st Team | 2nd Team |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | The Midnight Express |
|
1B
Josh Naylor
Cle |
SS
Gavin Lux
LAD |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | Gar in the House |
|
2B
Nolan Gorman
StL OF Wyatt Langford Tex |
SP
Walker Buehler
LAD SP Logan Webb SF |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | Garden City Wind |
|
1B
Bryce Harper
Phi OF Byron Buxton Min SS Jordan Lawlar Ari OF Dylan Crews Was 3B Coby Mayo Bal |
OF
Aaron Judge
NYA OF Randy Arozarena TB SP Zac Gallen Ari |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | Matzoh Marinara |
|
Round 4, 2nd Pick (2B Edouard Julien Min) |
RP
Devin Williams
Mil |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | Gizzy |
|
C
Bo Naylor
Cle |
Round 2, 4th Pick (3B Ke'Bryan Hayes Pit) |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | Matzoh Marinara |
|
SP
Chase Silseth
LAA |
Round 7, 8th Pick (SP Bryce Miller Sea) |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | George Brett |
|
SP
Tommy Henry
Ari |
Round 6, 12th Pick (2B Bryson Stott Phi) |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | Al Davis Templars |
|
Round 8, 2nd Pick (3B Brett Baty NYN) |
C
Endy Rodriguez
Pit |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | NYSE: AZO |
|
Round 9, 2nd Pick (C Keibert Ruiz Was) |
RP
Will Smith
KC |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | The Midnight Express |
|
Round 10, 2nd Pick (SP Yu Darvish SD) |
RP
Peter Fairbanks
TB |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | Dave's Destroyers |
|
3B
Nolan Arenado
StL |
OF
Christian Yelich
Mil Round 8, 11th Pick (SP Eduardo Rodriguez Ari) |
| Pre-Season | |
| Chaos Creators | Al Davis Templars |
|
Round 5, 2nd Pick (SS Carlos Correa Min) |
SP
Bobby Miller
LAD |